- name
SKILL.md
Die Skill-Datei bleibt im Repository des Herausgebers.
Fügen Sie den kopierten Befehl in ein Terminal ein. Er installiert diese SKILL.md in dem jeweiligen Agenten.
npx skills add Aperivue/medsci-skills --skill design-study -a cursor -yFügen Sie den kopierten Befehl in ein Terminal ein. Er installiert diese SKILL.md in dem jeweiligen Agenten.
npx skills add Aperivue/medsci-skills --skill design-study -a claude-code -yFügen Sie den kopierten Befehl in ein Terminal ein. Er installiert diese SKILL.md in dem jeweiligen Agenten.
npx skills add Aperivue/medsci-skills --skill design-study -a codex -yFügen Sie den kopierten Befehl in ein Terminal ein. Er installiert diese SKILL.md in dem jeweiligen Agenten.
npx skills add Aperivue/medsci-skills --skill design-study -a grok -ySenden Sie die kopierte Nachricht in einem Grok Bot-Chat. Der Bot ruft diese SKILL.md von GitHub ab und fügt sie den Skills hinzu, die alle Ihre Bots gemeinsam nutzen.
Install this skill: https://github.com/Aperivue/medsci-skills/tree/HEAD/skills/design-studyVom Herausgeber
Always inspect:
/define-variables before drafting Methods.## Study Design Review
Question: ...
Study type: ...
Analysis unit: ...
Index date / prediction timepoint: ...
### Strengths
- ...
### Major validity risks
1. ...
2. ...
### Minimal fixes
- ...
### Reporting fit
- Recommended guideline: ...
### Decision
- Ready for analysis / Needs redesign / Drafting can proceed with limitations
Cite a reference only with a /search-lit-confirmed DOI or PMID; mark any other [UNVERIFIED - NEEDS MANUAL CHECK]. Never invent a clinical definition, diagnostic criterion, or guideline recommendation: flag an unconfirmed one [VERIFY] and ask the user.
Extract from the protocol, draft, slides, tables, or notes: clinical problem, intended use case, population, inputs, outputs, outcome definition, and timing of variable availability.
Gate: Present the reconstructed study summary (question, analysis unit, intended use) to the user and confirm it before proceeding — a wrong reconstruction misdirects the entire validity review.
Read a reference only when its condition holds:
Look for mismatches: a patient-level claim from lesion-level analysis; an exam-level split with patient overlap; phase-level samples treated as independent.
Look for:
For any time-to-event or incident/transition design, check before drafting:
Check who established ground truth, when, whether blinding was possible, and whether only a subset had gold-standard verification. Then:
variable_operationalization.md. Methods definitions must match the
/define-variables operationalization table verbatim, and a blinded re-classification form must
quote the analytic protocol's definition verbatim. A paraphrase or "common-sense extension" in the
form is the documented cause of a low κ that is a definition mismatch, not real disagreement.Classify: apparent only, internal split, cross-validation, temporal, external, or multi-center external.
When the study elicits expert ratings — a reader study, an annotation panel, an AI-output evaluation —
read references/reader_elicitation_design.md before data collection. The acceptance ceiling of a
perceptual / reader AI study is fixed at design time: no quality of execution lifts a ceiling baked
into the comparator, the estimand, or the reader cohort. For an AI-system-versus-human-expert
benchmark, route to /design-ai-benchmarking (arm definition, LLM-as-judge versus human-as-judge
adjudication, structured export schema).
Ask whether the comparator and endpoint support the stated claim:
incremental_value.md; Kerr et
al., Epidemiology 2014). A standalone discrimination number does not support a "beyond X"
claim, and the nested-model comparison cannot be added post hoc without the baseline model.references/combine_models_ablation_design.md;references/multi_model_comparison_design.md;references/segmentation_failure_characterization_design.md. A mean DSC cannot be converted into
a usability claim after the fact.Recommend one primary guideline — TRIPOD+AI, CLAIM, STARD, STROBE (TARGET for a
target-trial emulation), PRISMA, CARE, or ARRIVE — plus journal-specific additions if needed.
No clinically relevant comparator; exam-level instead of patient-level split; unclear reference standard; AUROC-only reporting without threshold metrics.
Unclear time zero; immortal time bias; feature timing mismatch; no calibration.
references/target_trial_emulation.md.scripts/adjustment_set_helper.py (flags mediator /
collider / descendant adjustment and omitted confounders, and proposes a candidate backdoor set),
then derive the minimal sufficient set with dagitty — see references/dag_adjustment.md. At
review time /self-review Phase 2.5e and the O-probes in observational_confounding.md (O1–O18)
check this against Table 1 — including O7 over-adjustment, O10 overlapping-subset-gradient
discipline, O11 design-based weighting for complex-survey data, O12 data-driven-threshold mining,
O13 (a cross-sectional mediation claim cannot order X→M→Y), and O14 (a synergy/joint-effect claim
needs the additive interaction scale — RERI/AP/S — not a multiplicative-only test).No clear rubric for clinical correctness; benchmark labels derived from noisy reports without adjudication; unsupported claims about safety or workflow benefit; input text containing the target label or diagnosis being predicted; no same-backbone zero-shot/few-shot baseline for a fine-tuning or prompt-engineering claim.
Overlapping cohorts; paired modalities analyzed as independent; heterogeneity metrics missing; zero-cell handling unspecified.
Recommend the smallest feasible repair first: clarify the claim, narrow the target population, add a limitation statement, add a clinically relevant baseline, re-run one key sensitivity analysis, or redefine the endpoint more explicitly. Escalate to redesign only when the central claim is not defensible otherwise.
analyze-stats when the design is basically sound but analysis details need refinementcheck-reporting after the design is lockedself-review when the user wants a pre-submission quality check on their own manuscriptwrite-paper only after the main validity risks are documentedThis skill does not compute statistics, draft full manuscript prose, resolve raw data-engineering issues, or replace a full peer review when journal-facing tone is required.
Use when checking a radiology or medical AI study design before drafting or submission. Reviews the analysis unit, cohort logic, leakage risks, comparator, validation strategy and reporting-guideline
---name: design-studydescription: Use when checking a radiology or medical AI study design before drafting or submission. Reviews the analysis…---# skills/design-study/SKILL.mdÜbersicht
Use when checking a radiology or medical AI study design before drafting or submission. Reviews the analysis unit, cohort logic, leakage risks, comparator, validation strategy and reporting-guideline fit. AI-vs-expert benchmarks are /design-ai-benchmarking.
FAQ
Laden Sie skills/design-study/SKILL.md vom Herausgeber herunter oder kopieren Sie den Pfad und öffnen Sie das Repository. PlugMCP listet den Skill und hostet die Datei nicht.
Der Herausgeber pflegt es unter https://github.com/Aperivue/medsci-skills.
Claude, Cursor, Codex und Grok Build können eine SKILL.md lesen, die Sie aus dem Repository des Herausgebers hinzufügen. Grok Bot installiert sie, wenn Sie den Link zum GitHub-Ordner des Skills in einem Chat senden.
/self-reviewcheck_scope_coherence.pyCROSS_SECTIONAL_PROGNOSTICSURROGATE_CARE_DIRECTIVE