- name
SKILL.md
Die Skill-Datei bleibt im Repository des Herausgebers.
Fügen Sie den kopierten Befehl in ein Terminal ein. Er installiert diese SKILL.md in dem jeweiligen Agenten.
npx skills add BrianRWagner/ai-marketing-claude-code-skills --skill brand-positioning-audit -a cursor -yFügen Sie den kopierten Befehl in ein Terminal ein. Er installiert diese SKILL.md in dem jeweiligen Agenten.
npx skills add BrianRWagner/ai-marketing-claude-code-skills --skill brand-positioning-audit -a claude-code -yFügen Sie den kopierten Befehl in ein Terminal ein. Er installiert diese SKILL.md in dem jeweiligen Agenten.
npx skills add BrianRWagner/ai-marketing-claude-code-skills --skill brand-positioning-audit -a codex -yFügen Sie den kopierten Befehl in ein Terminal ein. Er installiert diese SKILL.md in dem jeweiligen Agenten.
npx skills add BrianRWagner/ai-marketing-claude-code-skills --skill brand-positioning-audit -a grok -ySenden Sie die kopierte Nachricht in einem Grok Bot-Chat. Der Bot ruft diese SKILL.md von GitHub ab und fügt sie den Skills hinzu, die alle Ihre Bots gemeinsam nutzen.
Install this skill: https://github.com/BrianRWagner/ai-marketing-claude-code-skills/tree/HEAD/brand-positioning-auditVom Herausgeber
Optimized for Claude Code, Cursor, and any AI that accepts markdown instructions. Run this immediately after gathering brand context.
Most brands don't have a messaging problem. They have a positioning problem — and bad messaging is the symptom.
"We help teams work better together" is not a positioning. Neither is "The leading platform for [category]." These sound like something, but they say nothing. They don't tell your ICP why you're the obvious choice. They don't separate you from the 47 competitors saying the same thing.
This audit diagnoses your positioning across 6 dimensions. Finds the root failure. Gives you specific rewrite-level fixes — not direction, actual copy you can use.
Detect from context or ask: "Quick diagnosis, full audit, or full audit with rewrites?"
Default: standard — use quick for fast direction. Use deep when you need ready-to-use copy alongside the diagnosis.
The AI must confirm all gates before running any analysis.
GATE CHECK — Required Before Starting
======================================
[ ] Brand URL provided (minimum required)
[ ] OR current messaging pasted directly (if no website)
[ ] ICP defined — optional but significantly improves diagnosis
[ ] Top competitors identified — optional but improves competitive separation scoring
[ ] Stated frustration with current positioning — optional, helps focus the audit
If URL is unavailable: ask user to paste homepage copy and about page copy.
Do not audit vague descriptions. Need actual messaging to analyze.
Ask for all inputs in a single message:
To run your brand positioning audit, give me:
1. Brand URL (homepage + about page if possible)
2. Current tagline or hero headline (if you know it)
3. Who you sell to — be specific. "B2B founders" is better than "businesses."
4. Your top 2-3 competitors (optional)
5. What specifically frustrates you about your current positioning? (optional — helps focus the audit)
If this is a re-audit: load prior audit scores and show deltas per dimension.
Fetch the brand's website and capture:
Score each of the 6 dimensions on a 1-10 scale:
Is it clear exactly who this is for?
A 10: The ICP is specific enough that someone could name 5 real people who fit. A 5: General category stated but no specificity (e.g., "for marketers" — which marketers? doing what? at what stage?) A 1: No indication of who this is for. Anyone could be the customer.
Evidence: Quote the exact copy that does or doesn't define ICP clearly.
Is the primary value proposition stated in concrete, outcome terms?
A 10: Specific outcome stated with a mechanism. "Cut your response time in half by routing support tickets automatically." A 5: Category stated but benefit is vague. "Streamline your workflow." A 1: No clear value stated. "The better way to work."
Evidence: Quote the exact copy that does or doesn't articulate value.
Does anything about this positioning make it impossible to swap with a competitor?
A 10: The position is specific enough that a competitor would need to fundamentally change their business to claim it. A 5: There's a differentiation angle but it's not owned — any competitor could claim it too with minor messaging changes. A 1: No differentiation. Interchangeable with every competitor.
Evidence: Quote the differentiation copy (or note its absence). Test: could a competitor say this exact thing?
Does the positioning feel earned, or asserted?
A 10: Specific numbers, named clients, before/after results, recognized validators. A 5: Some proof exists but it's vague or generic (e.g., "thousands of happy customers"). A 1: Pure assertion. Nothing to validate the claim.
Evidence: List what proof elements are present and rate their specificity.
Does the language match how the ICP actually talks about this problem?
A 10: The copy uses the exact phrases, pain points, and framing the ICP uses in their own words — not how the company wants to describe itself. A 5: Close, but there's noticeable inside-out language (features, capabilities, platform) rather than outside-in language (outcomes, pain, situation). A 1: The language is entirely internal. Sounds like how the founders talk about the product, not how customers talk about their problem.
Evidence: Quote 2-3 phrases that feel "inside-out" vs. how the ICP would actually phrase the problem.
Is there a clear reason to choose this over alternatives?
A 10: The positioning creates a specific comparison frame that makes competitors' alternatives look like wrong choices for the right buyer. A 5: Better/faster/cheaper than competitors — but doesn't explain why the comparison is one-sided. A 1: No competitive framing at all. Assumes the buyer has no alternatives.
Evidence: Quote competitive separation language (or note absence). Name the closest competitor — could they make the same claim?
After scoring all 6 dimensions, identify the single root failure. Don't list all problems — find the one that's causing the others.
Root failure types:
State: "The root failure is: [type] — [one sentence on why]"
# Brand Positioning Audit — [Brand Name]
*Audited: [Date] | Version 2.0*
## Scorecard
| Dimension | Score (1-10) | Notes |
|-----------|-------------|-------|
| ICP Clarity | [X] | [one-line summary] |
| Value Clarity | [X] | [one-line summary] |
| Differentiation | [X] | [one-line summary] |
| Proof Credibility | [X] | [one-line summary] |
| Message-Market Fit | [X] | [one-line summary] |
| Competitive Separation | [X] | [one-line summary] |
| **Overall** | **[avg]** | |
## Root Diagnosis
Root failure: **[type]**
[2-3 sentences on what's actually broken and why fixing the other dimensions won't matter until this is resolved]
## Evidence (verbatim from site)
Current hero: "[verbatim headline]"
Current sub: "[verbatim subheadline]"
What's missing: [specific element — ICP? outcome? proof? differentiation?]
## Priority Fixes
**Fix 1 (address root failure first):**
[Specific action — e.g., "Narrow the ICP from 'marketers' to 'solo consultant-founders doing their own marketing'"]
Why: [one sentence]
**Fix 2:**
[Specific action]
Why: [one sentence]
**Fix 3:**
[Specific action]
Why: [one sentence]
## Rewrite Pack
Three specific rewrites you can use now. No direction — actual copy.
**Option A — Benefit-forward:**
Headline: [rewrite]
Subheadline: [rewrite]
CTA: [rewrite]
**Option B — ICP-specific:**
Headline: [rewrite — leads with who it's for]
Subheadline: [rewrite]
CTA: [rewrite]
**Option C — Differentiation-led:**
Headline: [rewrite — leads with the owned position]
Subheadline: [rewrite]
CTA: [rewrite]
## Strategic Risks if Unchanged
1. [What happens if the root failure isn't fixed — specific consequence]
2. [Second risk]
3. [Third risk — may be competitive: "A competitor who positions against this exact gap will take your category"]
After generating the audit, run this mandatory review:
SELF-CRITIQUE — Audit Quality Check
=====================================
Scorecard accuracy (1-10): ___
- Are scores based on actual evidence from the site, not gut feel?
- Did I quote verbatim copy to justify each score?
Root failure specificity (1-10): ___
- Is the root failure one concrete thing, or a list of problems dressed up as one?
- If someone asked "what should I fix FIRST?" — is the answer obvious?
Rewrite quality (1-10): ___
- Are the three rewrites genuinely different positioning approaches?
- Or are they slight variations of the same idea?
- Would any of these headlines stop a cold prospect in the right direction?
Risks specificity (1-10): ___
- Are the strategic risks specific to this brand's situation?
- Or could they apply to any brand with a positioning problem?
If any score < 7: revise that section.
Improvements: [specific]
Overall: [one sentence — is this audit decision-quality?]
Present the refined audit. Then close with:
That's your brand positioning audit for [Brand].
Overall score: [X]/10 | Root failure: [type]
What's next?
A) Rewrite mode — I'll generate 3 more headline options for the strongest positioning angle
B) Competitor benchmark mode — I'll audit one competitor using the same scorecard and show where you have an advantage
C) Decision mode — You're choosing between two positioning directions; I'll evaluate each against the scorecard
D) Done — take the rewrites and implement
Reply with a letter or describe where you want to go.
If A — Rewrite Mode: Identify the highest-potential positioning angle from the audit. Generate 5 additional variations optimized for that angle. For each: note what it prioritizes (clarity / differentiation / ICP specificity / proof) and the context it's best suited for (homepage hero / sales deck / LinkedIn bio / cold outreach).
If B — Competitor Benchmark: Run the same 6-dimension scorecard on the named competitor. Present side-by-side:
Conclude: "Your clearest competitive advantage is [dimension]. The rewrite should exploit this."
If C — Decision Mode: Score each positioning direction candidate against the 6 dimensions. Recommend one. Explain why the other is weaker — specifically, which dimension it fails on and why that matters for their ICP.
Brand Positioning Audit v3.0.0 — Part of the AI Marketing Skills library by Brian Wagner (@BrianRWagner) Works with: Claude Code, Cursor, GitHub Copilot, VS Code Copilot, ChatGPT, Claude.ai
Use when founder/marketer needs to diagnose positioning problems (ICP clarity, differentiation, proof). Also: 'our positioning is generic', 'what makes us different', 'struggling to explain what we do
---name: brand-positioning-auditdescription: Use when founder/marketer needs to diagnose positioning problems (ICP clarity, differentiation, proof). Also…---# brand-positioning-audit/SKILL.mdÜbersicht
Use when founder/marketer needs to diagnose positioning problems (ICP clarity, differentiation, proof). Also: 'our positioning is generic', 'what makes us different', 'struggling to explain what we do', 'positioning is weak'. NOT for: copywriting, website design, long-form content creation.
FAQ
Laden Sie brand-positioning-audit/SKILL.md vom Herausgeber herunter oder kopieren Sie den Pfad und öffnen Sie das Repository. PlugMCP listet den Skill und hostet die Datei nicht.
Der Herausgeber pflegt es unter https://github.com/BrianRWagner/ai-marketing-claude-code-skills.
Claude, Cursor, Codex und Grok Build können eine SKILL.md lesen, die Sie aus dem Repository des Herausgebers hinzufügen. Grok Bot installiert sie, wenn Sie den Link zum GitHub-Ordner des Skills in einem Chat senden.